Edgewonk is for the trader who enjoys the post-mortem as much as the trade. It is a paid journal with a deep analytics and psychology toolkit. Journal Trading is a free web journal that tries to make the weekly review short enough to repeat. The choice is less about which one has more charts, and more about whether you will use the depth.
The short answer
- ▸Start with Journal Trading if you trade MT5 or cTrader, want a free core journal, and need setup, session and prop firm tracking more than a research lab.
- ▸Pay for Edgewonk if you already have a strategy and enough history to analyse, and you want to test specific hypotheses about setups, sessions, exits and discipline.
- ▸Edgewonk costs $197 per year, billed every 12 months, with VAT possibly added. There is no free plan, though public pages advertise a 14-day money-back guarantee.
- ▸Journal Trading's web journal is free, as are CSV import and the MT5 connector. The cTrader plugin may be paid through the cTrader Store.
- ▸Depth costs time. A paid tool you do not open is more expensive than a free tool you use every week.
Edgewonk is not an impulse purchase. If you cannot name the three questions you want it to answer, start with the free journal and come back when the questions are sharper.
Decision matrix
| Criterion | Edgewonk | Journal Trading | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry cost | $197/year, no free plan | Free web journal | Budget |
| Depth | Chart Lab, Edge Finder, MFE/MAE, simulator | Core stats, calendar, setups and sessions | Research |
| Psychology | Psychology Lab, Tiltmeter, routines | Emotions, plan adherence, AI coach if configured | Discipline |
| Import | Hundreds of brokers, MT4/MT5, cTrader, Excel | MT5, CSV, cTrader where available | Import time |
| Accounts | Unlimited broker and prop accounts per pricing page | Multi-account journal | Challenges |
| Simulator | Performance simulator and strategy testing | Not built in | Validation |
| Trial | 14-day money-back guarantee | Free to start | Risk |
| Language | Check current interface languages | English and French | Comfort |
Where Edgewonk goes further
Its advantage is not one feature but the ability to keep asking narrower questions. Chart Lab, cross filters, MFE and MAE analysis, best hours and weekdays, trade management optimisation and the performance simulator let you test a hypothesis instead of staring at a general dashboard. For a trader with enough history, that can shorten the research cycle considerably.
Psychology is the other strong point. Psychology Lab, Tiltmeter, routines and checklists turn discipline into a measured variable. If you know your losses come from inconsistent rule following, this toolkit goes further than a single emotion field per trade. It is also the part that demands the most personal work: the tool measures, it does not correct.
On imports, Edgewonk advertises hundreds of brokers, automatic MT4 and MT5 sync, cTrader support and Excel import. Its pricing page mentions unlimited broker and prop firm accounts. For a trader running several evaluations, that is a concrete argument. The limits sit elsewhere: an annual subscription, real setup time, and a depth that can become a form of procrastination when it is not tied to a decision.
The honest caveat is sample size. Depth pays when you have enough trades for the subgroups to mean something. Twenty trades split by setup, session and weekday produce tiny buckets that look like insights but are mostly noise. If your history is thin, the useful move is to build the journaling habit first and postpone the research.
What Journal Trading covers without a subscription
Journal Trading does not try to match a research lab. It covers the loop many traders skip: recording trades, computing net P&L, reading the calendar, comparing setups and sessions, and tracking prop firm limits. The MT5 connector is free and read-only, CSV import is free, and cTrader connects through OAuth 24/7 where the broker supports it.
The cTrader WebView plugin is also read-only, but it may be paid through the cTrader Store. The web journal is therefore not an unqualified "everything free" offer: the core is free, MT5 and CSV are free, and some optional integrations may be charged. None of them can execute an order.
The free core is not a seven-day demo that expires. You can start without a card, import a real month and run a full review. That matters because the first decision is not whether Edgewonk is deeper; it is whether you will journal consistently at all. A free core answers that question before you spend $197.
The difference from Edgewonk is deliberate: fewer custom reports, no performance simulator, no built-in backtesting, narrower native coverage. For a beginner or a trader with fewer than 100 trades a year, that depth would often be noise. For a trader with a stable strategy who wants to optimise it, it can become the centre of the work.
The real one-year price
| Option | Price | Monthly equivalent | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edgewonk annual | $197/year | $16.42 | VAT may apply |
| Edgewonk monthly | $35/month | $35 | If offered |
| Journal Trading web | $0 | $0 | Core journal |
| MT5 and CSV | $0 | $0 | Read-only |
| cTrader plugin | Varies | Varies | Store listing |
At $197 a year, Edgewonk costs less over twelve months than TradeZella's annual plans at the prices we checked, but it is still a commitment. Over three years, the bill reaches $591 before VAT. The monthly option, if offered, totals $420 a year. VAT varies by country: at the time of checking, the official page listed about $236.40 for France, including 20% VAT.
Prices checked in October 2026. They may change, and the official page may show a monthly option or different promotions. Check the Edgewonk pricing page before choosing. On the Journal Trading side, the web journal is free, the MT5 connector and CSV import are free, and the cTrader plugin may be paid through the cTrader Store.
The 14-day money-back guarantee is not a free trial: you pay first. Use the window to test a real import, not to browse menus.
Importing trades
Edgewonk advertises broad coverage: hundreds of brokers, automatic MT4 and MT5 sync, cTrader, and Excel import for platforms that are not listed. Broker and prop firm accounts are unlimited according to its pricing page. That is useful if you run several challenges or separate strategies by account.
Journal Trading is simpler: read-only MT5, CSV, and cTrader where OAuth sync is available. CSV is versatile, but you must map columns and check fees. For an MT5 forex trader, the native connection is often enough. For a multi-platform trader, Edgewonk requires less improvisation.
- ▸Reconcile one month of net P&L against the broker statement, not just the trade count.
- ▸Check commissions, swaps and platform fees.
- ▸Confirm the time zone and daylight saving treatment.
- ▸Look for duplicates, partial fills and trades attached to the wrong account.
- ▸Normalise instrument names before comparing several brokers.
Import is not the product: it is the condition for a reliable review. A tool that imports quickly but loses fees gives you false confidence, and false confidence costs more than a manual import.
Analytics: how far to go
Edgewonk is built to go deep. MFE and MAE reports, drawdown, losing streaks, best setups and best hours, trade management optimisation and the performance simulator answer questions that basic statistics do not. Edge Finder scans the journal regularly to surface strengths, weaknesses and improvement areas, according to the vendor's pages.
Journal Trading sticks to the metrics that support a weekly review: net P&L, win rate, profit factor, expectancy, drawdown, the P&L calendar, results by setup, session and weekday. Our performance analysis guide explains how to read them, and the weekly review offers a five-step method.
Most traders need five answers:
- ▸Which setup makes money after fees?
- ▸Which session or weekday destroys the most performance?
- ▸What is the real drawdown, not just the worst day?
- ▸What percentage of trades follows the plan?
- ▸Which mistake recurs most, and what does it cost in R?
If those five answers fit on one page, extra depth is a useful luxury only when you have a precise question. If you spend Sundays exploring reports without changing a rule, the tool has become entertainment.
A useful way to judge the extra depth is to write one decision rule before you open the reports. For example: "If the London session is negative after 50 trades, I stop trading it for a month." Then see which tool makes that rule easy to test. Depth that cannot be turned into a rule is just a nicer way to look at the past.
Psychology and discipline
This is where Edgewonk separates itself most clearly. Psychology Lab, Tiltmeter, routines and checklists let you track discipline as a variable rather than an impression. If you know your losses come from moved stops or trades taken after a loss, this gives you a structured way to measure the problem and follow progress.
Journal Trading lets you record emotions and plan adherence for every trade, and offers an AI coach when AI is configured. It is lighter, but connected to the numbers. For many traders, that is enough to reveal overtrading, revenge trading or early exits.
Either way, the tool shows the pattern; it does not make the rule automatic. Psychology is built with written rules, a daily loss limit and a pause after two losses. Our trading psychology article covers those guardrails. If you want a structured psychological framework, Edgewonk is more developed; if you want a lightweight habit, Journal Trading is enough.
Who should choose which
Choose Edgewonk if:
- ▸You already have a strategy and enough trade history to analyse.
- ▸You like testing precise hypotheses about setups, sessions and trade management.
- ▸Psychology and discipline are the main leak in your results.
- ▸You manage several accounts and accept an annual subscription.
Choose Journal Trading if:
- ▸You trade on MetaTrader 5 or cTrader and want free import.
- ▸You need a free journal for a prop firm challenge.
- ▸You want to start without a credit card or a commitment.
- ▸You prefer a French or English interface and readable statistics.
- ▸You accept CSV import for platforms that are not natively covered.
The expensive mistake is not choosing the simpler tool. It is paying for depth you will not use. A trader who opens the journal for five minutes a day does not need a laboratory. A trader who spends two hours a week testing hypotheses does not need the interface simplified to the point where it hides the data.
Annual billing deserves its own test. The annual price assumes twelve months of use. If you trade seasonally, take long breaks or are still deciding whether this is the year you commit to journaling, a free core journal is the lower-risk place to build the habit. You can always upgrade once the habit exists and the questions are specific.
A 7-day test protocol
The goal is not to compare every feature, but to see whether Edgewonk's depth answers questions the free journal leaves open.
- ▸Day 1: write three precise questions about your trading, such as which setup loses most or which session is most expensive.
- ▸Day 2: import six months of trades into Journal Trading via MT5 or CSV. Reconcile net P&L against the broker statement.
- ▸Day 3: run a 30-minute review and note which questions the tool does not answer clearly.
- ▸Day 4: open Edgewonk, import the same period and repeat exactly the same review.
- ▸Day 5: compare the answers to your three questions. Note the time spent and how easy it was to find the information.
- ▸Day 6: test the psychology workflow and data export. Confirm you could leave without losing your history.
- ▸Day 7: decide before the refund window closes. If you are not continuing, request the refund and keep one journal.
Pass criteria:
- ▸Import and reconciliation take less than an hour.
- ▸You answer your three questions without outside help.
- ▸The review can be repeated weekly without reconfiguring the tool.
- ▸The extra depth changes at least one trading decision.
FAQ
Does Edgewonk have a free plan? No. The annual plan is $197, billed every 12 months, with VAT possibly added. A monthly option at $35 may appear on the official page; check the current terms. A 14-day money-back guarantee is advertised on public pages.
Is Journal Trading really free? The web journal is free, as are CSV import and the MT5 connector. The cTrader plugin may be paid through the cTrader Store, and some optional features may depend on your configuration. The core journal is not a time-limited trial.
Is Edgewonk only for forex? No. Its pricing page mentions forex, stocks, futures, crypto, options, indices and commodities. Exact coverage depends on the platforms and imports available for your broker.
Does Edgewonk import MetaTrader 5? Yes, its import page mentions automatic sync for MT4 and MT5, plus Excel import for unlisted platforms. Verify your broker and account type on the current list.
Are Journal Trading's statistics enough? For a weekly review and prop firm tracking, yes in most cases. If you need MFE/MAE analysis, strategy testing or a performance simulator, Edgewonk offers depth the free journal does not have.
Sources
Prices checked in October 2026. The pages below were accessed in October 2026; offers and prices may change.