Filling in your trading journal is not enough: reviewing it is what makes you improve. Traders who really get better almost all have a regular ritual to analyze their trades with a cool head, away from the screen and the emotions of the session. A weekly review is the most effective format: frequent enough to correct quickly, spaced enough to have a meaningful sample of trades.
Preparing the review
Block 30 to 45 minutes on the weekend, always at the same time. Make sure every trade of the week is in the journal with its screenshot and notes. If you use a spreadsheet, start from our journal template; if you trade on MetaTrader 5, the MT5 connector has already imported everything.
Step 1: the week's numbers
- ▸Net P&L (after fees) and total result in R
- ▸Number of trades compared with your usual average
- ▸Win rate, average win and average loss in R
- ▸Profit factor for the week
- ▸Largest equity drawdown and longest losing streak
Do not stop at P&L: a winning week can hide bad habits, and a losing week can be perfectly executed. Trends over several weeks are what matter.
Step 2: plan adherence
For each trade, ask one simple question: did it follow all my rules (setup, time, risk, stop)? Then compute two numbers: the share of trades that followed the plan, and the result of compliant trades versus off-plan trades. In most cases, off-plan trades explain the bulk of losses.
💡 Aim for at least 90% compliant trades. Below that, the problem is not your strategy but your execution.
Step 3: best and worst trades
Review your three best and three worst trades with their screenshots. For the best: what did they have in common (setup, time, market context)? For the worst: did the mistake come from analysis, execution or trade management? Write one concrete takeaway for each.
Step 4: recurring mistakes
- ▸Early entry, before the planned confirmation
- ▸Stop moved or removed during the trade
- ▸Winners cut too early for fear of giving them back
- ▸Revenge trading after a loss
- ▸Overtrading: trades taken out of boredom or outside your hours
- ▸Position size inconsistent with your risk rule
Count how often each mistake appeared and what it cost you in R. It is often the most motivating number of the review.
Step 5: one goal for next week
Pick a single, measurable goal tied to your process, not to results. For example: "zero moved stops", "maximum three trades per session" or "only trade the London session". Next week, start the review by checking that goal.
Analyzing by setup, day and hour
Once a month, go further: compare results by setup, weekday and hour. Many traders find that a single setup or session carries all of their performance, and that dropping the rest is enough to become profitable. Our performance analysis guide covers the metrics, and the market hours help you place your sessions.
The mental side
Finish with your state of mind: fatigue, stress, overconfidence, personal events. Link them to your results: the data often shows that bad days start before the first trade. Read our trading psychology article to go further.
The trading journal computes every statistic of this review and the P&L calendar automatically: all that is left is the analysis.
FAQ
Daily or weekly review? They complement each other: 5 minutes every evening to fill in the journal, 30 to 45 minutes on the weekend to analyze.
How many trades before drawing conclusions? One week gives hints; to judge a strategy, wait for at least 30 to 50 trades.