Many futures traders start on Excel or Google Sheets. It is free, but futures contracts have specifics — tick value, multiplier, commissions — that make the spreadsheet fragile. This guide compares a spreadsheet and a dedicated journal, to understand when to switch to a specialised tool.
What the spreadsheet does well
- ▸Free and customisable
- ▸A list of trades with P&L
- ▸Basic formulas: sum, average, win rate
- ▸No dependency on an online service
For a few occasional trades, a spreadsheet is enough. Our trading journal template gives you the basic columns.
What the spreadsheet handles poorly on futures
| Futures specificity | Why the spreadsheet struggles |
|---|---|
| Tick value | Different per contract (MNQ $0.50, MES $1.25, CL $10…): needs a reference table |
| Multiplier | P&L = (exit − entry) × multiplier × quantity: easy to break |
| Commissions | Per contract, sometimes per side: one omission falsifies everything |
| Multiple contracts | MNQ, MES, ES, NQ… each with its own calculation rules |
💡 An error on a single contract's multiplier (e.g. ×20 instead of ×2 for MNQ) multiplies your displayed P&L by 10. That is the classic spreadsheet trap.
What the dedicated journal brings
- ▸Tick value and multiplier known automatically per contract
- ▸Per-contract commissions accounted for
- ▸Automatic trade import (MT5, NinjaTrader/Tradovate CSV…)
- ▸Statistics by session, setup and hour
- ▸Cloud access, no formulas to maintain
The futures trading journal does all of this for free, in the cloud.
When to switch from spreadsheet to a dedicated journal
- ▸As soon as you trade several different contracts
- ▸When commissions weigh on your real P&L
- ▸When you have already falsified a multiplier calculation
- ▸When you waste time re-entering your trades
For the method, read our how to keep a trading journal guide.
FAQ
Can a spreadsheet calculate tick value? Yes, with a per-contract reference table, but you must maintain it and avoid formula errors.
When does a dedicated journal become essential? As soon as you trade several contracts or commissions distort your P&L reading.
Can I import my Excel history? Yes, most journals accept a CSV import. Export your spreadsheet and import it.