To pass a prop firm challenge, it is not enough to track your P&L: you must track precise rules — daily loss, drawdown, profit target, consistency, payout. A generic journal is not enough. This comparison helps you choose the right tool so you never break a rule by oversight. For the broader picture, read our best trade journal comparison.
What a prop firm journal must track
- ▸Daily loss and the buffer left before the limit
- ▸Drawdown (static or trailing) and your distance to the ceiling
- ▸The profit target remaining
- ▸The estimated payout, after profit split
- ▸The consistency rule: no single day may weigh too much
The available options
| Option | Strengths | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Dedicated prop firm journal | Automatic rule tracking (daily loss, drawdown, payout) | None really |
| Spreadsheet (Excel / Sheets) | Free, customisable | Manual rule calculation, easy mistakes |
| Generic journal | Basic statistics | Does not track prop firm rules |
| Paper notes | Simple | No statistics |
💡 The key difference: a prop firm journal computes drawdown and daily loss automatically. A spreadsheet makes you calculate them by hand — and that is where breaches happen.
The selection criteria
- ▸Automatic tracking of daily loss and drawdown (static and trailing)
- ▸Profit target and estimated payout
- ▸Automatic trade import (MT5, cTrader, CSV)
- ▸Separate accounts for multiple challenges
- ▸Cloud access, from any device
The prop firm trading journal by Journal Trading checks every box: free, cloud-based, with read-only MT5 and cTrader import.
Why not stick to a spreadsheet?
A spreadsheet can work for personal trading, but prop firm rules add complexity we underestimate: trailing drawdown follows your equity peak, consistency caps each day, daily loss depends on floating equity. Every formula mistake is a potential breach. Read our prop firm journal vs spreadsheet comparison to understand the difference in detail.
FAQ
What is the best journal for a prop firm? A dedicated journal that automatically tracks daily loss, drawdown and payout. Spreadsheets and generic journals do not.
Is a spreadsheet enough for a challenge? Yes if you are rigorous, but the risk of a calculation error on trailing drawdown is high. A dedicated journal removes that risk.
Can I track several challenges? Yes, with a journal that lets you separate accounts. Each challenge has its own rules.